Fraught communication
The difficulties of language is something that I think about often. I guess that it's at the forefront of a lot of the writing on here; a kind of self consciousness around feeling as though I'm not a particularly good writer. Being a visual person, I don't find it easy to bring out what I want to say through words. I might say one thing, but I really mean another. I feel that I always miss a beat. But one must try their best to communicate, because being silent will not get you anywhere in life. Here's a few things that dance around the idea of communication:
Physical communication
I was on the Victoria Line. Two teenaged boys made quite a strong entrance into the carriage by aggressively throwing themselves down onto seats opposite each other. One boy threw a newspaper at the other boy. I didn't hear laughter. I then watched as they communicated to each other through sign language. There would be an occasional pause as one boy would try to find the right word, while the other waited intently. At one point, one of them picked up the newspaper, crossed his leg, and pretended to mimic the old English gentleman sitting next to him.
Semi-extinct languages
Just yesterday, while spending an afternoon in my dear friend Valerie's pottery studio, a woman on holiday from Germany came in to look around. We got talking about Europe, particularly the difficulties of sharing borders with multiple countries with different political crises and agendas. She later mentioned that she had just been conducting 'field work' research in Papua New Guinea. This involved documenting how semi-extinct languages, such as 'Qaqet' (only spoken by 15,000 people) is transmitted. I found this really interesting, not only because I ashamedly lack awareness of Papua New Guinean culture and history, but because I was struck by the fact that a non-written language can become extinct. However I was aware that prior to colonisation in Australia, there were over 250 Indigenous languages specific to different clans. Only 40 of these languages are still spoken today due to the ongoing decimation of Indigenous culture as a result of policies made by settlers. I read this article from The Conversation that briefly addresses the difficult link between Indigenous language and culture: "we have our culture, a strong culture- but without language, how are you supposed to keep it going?"
A Portrait of Cate Blanchett
I keep returning to a film work by David Rosetzky that I saw in an Australian portraiture exhibition last year. A Portrait of Cate Blanchett focuses on the actor as she moves through a barren workshop used for the construction of theatre sets at the Sydney Theatre Company. The setting nicely complements the film's exploration of artistic process and the creation of fiction. The film begins with a close-up of Blanchett's hands; one hand moulding the other into different gestures. Although the hands are performing this action, rather than Robert Bresson's imagery of innocent hands devoid of acting, the image from Portrait instantly brought to mind this great Bresson quote: "how many useless and encumbered words disappear when things are expressed with the hand, the head, the shoulders!" The camera then moves backwards to gradually reveal either in-focus or blurry vision of Blanchett as the digital camera lens is changed. Blanchett's voiceover begins by exploring the inconsistencies of identity: what is seen and unseen. She finishes with a comment on interpretation: "I realised that exactly what I thought I was communicating would be received by someone in a completely different way- you can't control it. You have to give interpretation over."
In Todd Field's 2022 film TÁR, Blanchett plays a narcissistic conductor, Lydia Tár, who purposefully speaks in a way that eludes clear interpretation. When discussing music with her orchestra or with peers, she uses ambiguous allegories to describe what she's trying to achieve. I believe that the character performs in this way in order to alienate and gain the upper hand over people; one of many examples of her narcissistic personality and constant vie for power. There's a revealing moment in the film's second half where she cries alone while watching her inspiration, Leonard Bernstein talk about music's emotional affects. It's as though Tár is lamenting the fact that she's spent so much of her life performing a contrived version of herself and never been able to speak directly with an audience. Bernstein gets to the core of what music achieves without over embellishing his point. I liked what Bernstein said, so I'll take note of it: "music is the way it makes you feel when you hear it... you don't need to know a lot of stuff about sharps and chords to understand it. Some of those feelings are so special, so deep that you can't even describe them in words. We can't always name the things we feel."
 |
| A still from A Portrait of Cate Blanchett |